School district’s woes topped year’s headlines

Good or bad, news revolving around the Lynwood Unified School District headquarters on Bullis Road dominated the 2009 year in the city of Lynwood.

By MARISELA SANTANA, Staff Writer

Tools

LYNWOOD — From the inauguration of the country’s first Black president to the welcomed presence of county Supervisor Mark Ridley-Thomas in the Second District, 2009’s headlines here featured a little bit of everything.

As the year comes to a close, headlines about a fence finally being put up across the street from an elementary school, foreclosures in Lynwood being at an all-time high, the grand opening of a long-awaited park taking place or the tragic killing of a beloved city employee at City Hall topped the news at one time or another. But looking back, it was headlines over the turmoil in the Lynwood Unified School District that seemed to overwhelm what will be remembered from 2009.

The district definitely had its ups, including when Lynwood High School teacher Ana Higuera was named a Milken Family Foundation Award recipient recently and when middle school students took home awards at regional decathlon competitions in Orange County. But unfortunately, those grand accolades weren’t the headlines that defined 2009 in the district.

That honor would go to the district’s innumerable lows, starting with a controversial 3-1 vote to reconfigure district boundaries that would wipe out continuity at any of the schools, leaving some elementary schools students from kindergarten to fifth grade, and others serving kindergarten through sixth grade, one high school serving ninth through 12 grade and another serving 10th through 12th grade, and some middle schools serving sixth through eighth grades and others serving seventh through ninth.

Because of changes in the district’s demographics, the inconsistencies between the schools was necessary, according to a consultant the board hired back in 2008.

Looming over the district for years, turmoil in the district finally hit the fan in 2009 as school board members realized the district was going under due to gross deficit spending. But time wasn’t all that ran out. So did the district’s general funds.

The county’s District Assistant Intervention Team stepped in to oversee the district when its state Academic Performance Index score came back at 666. A 300-page report by the team also exposed problems that may have gotten the district to where it is — problems the county is currently trying to fix.

By April, teachers knew they had gotten the short end of the stick. Years of saving teachers’ jobs when other districts were making drastic cuts, had finally caught up to LUSD. And even though some of the unions agreed to four furlough days, 191 teachers still got layoff notices.

More problems arose when teachers accused the district of not knowing seniority even if it slapped them in the face. Then in mid-April, 43 layoff notices were rescinded. But when news that funds from the state weren’t coming, the district had to take back those rescinded letters. And when June came, the board voted to layoff 78 teachers.

The teachers union, which had its own problems throughout the year, then negotiated a 3 percent cut for all of its members to save those jobs from being cut. The decision was put to a member vote and it prevailed, but many in the membership disagreed with the election’s process saying it was rushed through. While having to take a 3 percent cut to save their colleagues’ jobs is the biggest gesture anybody could make, it may not make a difference because more cuts are on the way.

The district is now operating with a $26.4 million deficit. That number is expected to reach $50 million in 2010-11.

In all of this, as the district celebrated the first graduating class of Firebaugh High School, the district was finding itself navigating through a tidal wave of panic over the arrest of one of its administrators, Jonas Silverio, the principal at Firebaugh.

Maneuvering through the news with trepidation, school board members in May placed Silverio on administrative leave upon hearing the Sheriff’s Department’s Special Victims Bureau was involved. Eventually, Silverio resigned. He was arrested in July.

He pleaded not guilty, but is now facing 18 counts of committing lewd acts on children. In October, two former Firebaugh students, along with three other former students of Silverio at other schools, testified against him. A public defender was assigned to the former principal, and a trial date is now pending.

Dhyan Lal, the district’s superintendent, was also placed under a microscope. After years of questioning his leadership and alleged wrongdoings, parents and teachers finally got their wish in August when school board members decided it was time for a change. But his contract, in which he helped to etch in stone with the help of a law firm still contracted by the school district, didn’t allow for a change. Though officially relieved of his duties as superintendent, he’s still on the district’s payroll for another year for $17,000 a month.

The five-member school board is also being held to answer for the district being on the brink of destruction. Some of them signed off on Lal’s $250,000 a year contract. The county’s probe, along with a second audit conducted by a state agency hired by the five school board members, have revealed actual dollars that were misspent, misused or misappropriated.

Despite more and more parents working together for the better of all Lynwood children — including the formation of a new parent group called African-American Parents for Academic Excellence — turmoil in the district still lingers in different corners. Teacher and principal behavior is now under scrutiny as investigations are under way. Some for hitting students. Some for threatening students. Some for inappropriate behavior with students. And some for just not doing their jobs.

The school board is being led by an acting superintendent, but members vow to do their best to make things right, including hiring a permanent superintendent who will help make those changes. The acting superintendent isn’t interested in the permanent job.

Even though some of his tactics and past are being questioned, his management in keeping the district afloat is working. The board should probably look to a new policy LAUSD Superintendent Ramon Cortines is putting together to get rid of the bad apples in the district.

While change is desperately needed at the district level, voters didn’t seem to think so when Nov. 3 came along. Voters re-elected Alfonso Morales and Rachel Chavez to the school board. And two weeks ago, Jose Luis Solache was re-elected school board president for his second consecutive year. The changes the district needs will still come, the board members promise.

Things on the other side of Bullis Road have been pretty quiet this year. The city manager and City Council members continue to clean up debris left over from years past. Old contracts are finally being put up for bids. Trees are being cut on time. Homes are being built with the humanitarian efforts of Habitat for Humanity.

The city’s first senior housing complex is now being lived in. Residents are enjoying their brand new park. Water rate increases were deferred for another year. And surveillance cameras are aiding the Sheriff’s Department in policing the city.

Most importantly, crime is the lowest its been in 25 years. Prostitution has been curbed and so far there have been two homicides this year.

The city’s first homicide happened in the city’s own back yard. Adolfo Medina a 31-year city employee, was found shot to death in the city’s public works yard on the morning of July 1. The suspect in this case is still at large. City Council members named a new playground in honor of Medina.

On Nov. 3, a heated City Council race also resulted in the re-election of all three incumbents. In the end, it was a tight race between Councilman Ramon Rodriguez and former City Treasurer Iris Pygatt by mere votes that resulted in Rodriguez being re-elected by two votes.

Pygatt would have joined Maria Santillan and Aide Castro as the first woman majority in Lynwood’s history.

The city has had to make more than $6.2 million in cuts over the last two years, and finds itself having to operate within its means.

Residents came out in full support of the city’s first ever Cash for Chunkers weight loss challenge. With more than 100 participants in what was also called the Mayor’s Waist Stimulus Package, 42 teams battled to the finish line and lost a combined 1,541 pounds. The winning team was called the Fantastic 4 and included city employees Bruno Naulls, Roger Haley, Jamel Goodloe and Jose Trejo. They lost 16 percent of their weight each. The individual grand prize winner was Alfonso Morales Sr.

The most recent headline to cause alarm was published last week when it was learned that an appeals court had ruled in favor of Angeles Fields Partners — the developer behind the infamous NFL project that would have uprooted more than 1,000 families from the city’s northeast area. Previous council members awarded an exclusive negotiating agreement to the developer before being officially unseated by a recall election that ousted four of them. An injunction put a halt to the last-minute amendments and newly seated council members canceled the contract.

The developer took the city to court and lost. He appealed the decision and a few weeks ago it was learned that the state’s Second District Appellate Court ruled in his favor. The city is planning on counter appealing.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

PI Again said on Tuesday, Apr 6 at 3:35 PM

By "his," I was referring to the former superintendent.

40758353
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

PI said on Tuesday, Apr 6 at 3:33 PM

PI stands for Program Improvement. It is a special status reserved for failing schools and districts. When a school or a district does not meet its goals on standardized tests for a certain number of consecutive years, the State will give it PI status. Once in PI, a school or a district has a limited time to improve before it faces takeover by the State. It is not a positive status; schools and districts must work really hard to get out of PI. Teachers don't want to work for PI schools and districts, and informed parents don't want their kids to attend PI schools. And no, LUSD's PI status doesn't have any direct link with his contract with the Board.

40758253
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Declining Attendance said on Sunday, Mar 7 at 11:21 PM

Hey the district has had a 20% drop in attendance while building 4 new schools. How about closing some of the poor performing older schools to cut costs and reduce teacher layoffs? Example: Roosevelt and Lugo. They make fine shopping centers.

38850217
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

What is PI? said on Thursday, Mar 4 at 12:21 AM

What is PI? Does it have anything to do with paying Dr. Lal to not work?

38641632
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To Go Lynwood said on Wednesday, Mar 3 at 8:40 AM

The best district in L.A. County? Are you kidding? Have you heard of LBUSD? LUSD has been in PI for more than 3 years.

38587744
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Go Lynwood said on Tuesday, Mar 2 at 11:45 PM

This is the best school district in LA County. All the problems here are just parents who are jealous at how the school board has to do more with less money. If you want better schools move to Palos Verdes or Beverly Hills.

38570241
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

What woes? said on Saturday, Feb 27 at 8:01 PM

District just paid lawyers $600,000. They must have plenty of money! I trust this school board. They always try to do what is right for the students. President Solache works hard to make Lynwood the best school district in LA.

38405224
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Sunday, Feb 21 at 8:42 PM

Well if the rents are too high, fight back! Recall the board that allowed all our money to get away.

38020927
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Rents higher said on Saturday, Feb 20 at 11:38 PM

I wanted to move my family to Bellflower or Paramount but the rents are higher there cause they got good schools and not broke.Lynwood families are trapped

37984652
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Saturday, Feb 20 at 6:19 PM

The whole lot of them are incompetant.You or I could hire experts to to do what we can't, so why are they even there? I don't get it!But the residents of Lynwood love them. They've taken LUSD to the poor house,and te residents voted them right back in.

37975166
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

I'm Shocked said on Thursday, Feb 18 at 10:52 PM

Is that comment true? Lynwood was only school district out of the whole LA County to declare they were short of funds? How could the School Board have allowed this? I see people knocking and picking on Solache, but what about the rest of the Board? Where were they all? Now they want to borrow $5,000,000 from the State of California to carry them through to end of school year in June. Ouch!

37872198
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

No Doc here said on Sunday, Feb 14 at 4:30 PM

The Board is just following the Fine Art of going slowly nowhere at great expense! Any scared deer in the headlights found on Bullis Rd?

37598141
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Sunday, Feb 14 at 1:05 AM

So the board is doodling up there,and the speakers are just filling the air with sounds. Charlie Brown style

37575466
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

An Answer said on Saturday, Feb 13 at 11:12 PM

Hint: Expect nothing to happen until the next crisis comes along, and you won't be disappointed!

37574061
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Question? said on Friday, Feb 12 at 1:54 AM

I have seen and heard many concerned individuals express themselves about endless topics to the school board. When does the dialogue began? When are the questions answered? Is it just a venting session or what?What is really suppose to happen?

37475941
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

I hear those rumors said on Thursday, Feb 11 at 8:26 PM

May 1 will require state intervention. The deficit won't be below 200% of cash. Only problem is that some folks think there is monies hidden away to bail this district out. I hope so, or the school board will be extinct like the dodo bird.

37468726
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Haters and groupies said on Wednesday, Feb 10 at 10:19 AM

Looks like LUSD has a groupie. He spends lots of time here and posts funny comments from the comfort of his armchair. Nothing better to do, Doc?

37369169
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Ex Firebaugh Teacher said on Wednesday, Feb 10 at 1:22 AM

The parents are probably too busy working and trying to hold onto their jobs in this lousy economy to realize the mess LUSD is in! How many actually show up at Open House?

37345029
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Takeover soon said on Tuesday, Feb 9 at 11:28 PM

Prediction, takeover May 1. Lynwood Unified is only one of 85 districts in LA County to certify that it could not comply with the state and county budgetary requirements for funds availablility. In effect, this district is so poorly run that they do not think they can remain locally governed. Again, only district in LA County financially wrecked. Parents, you re-elected the school board even though they withheld the FCMAT information until after the election. Thus they stole the election while voters were napping! Why isn't there a recall to save the District? Are you happy with the new watered down graduation requirements and the proposed huge increase in class size? Why have the parents not protested?

37343266
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Too much negative said on Thursday, Feb 4 at 11:32 PM

Too much negative and bad vibes on here. We need to be positive about Lynwood Successes! 1. Graduation rates will be going up because curriculum will be for going to vocational school after graduation. College? A dream! 2. School Board always knows what is best for students. After all, not long ago most were students in Lynwood. 3. District Administration is always right! Lal told School Board what to do and they rubber stamped his suggestions including his iron clad contract. 4. Lets all be positive about one thing. Parents voted to re-elect school board members. So Parents want this School Board. Stay positive, be positive, and positively the State of California will be your new school board!

37037982
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

The best leave said on Sunday, Jan 31 at 11:52 AM

The top students want to go to college. They "move" to Bellflower, Downey, Paramount to high schools with higher test scores. The rest of the students stay in Lynwood and will now be receiving a "watered down" education.

36724877
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Saturday, Jan 30 at 12:06 AM

The board isdoing away with requirements so they can do away with those teachers that teach those courses.They're searching for money off the backs of the students. I guess they don't care if the kids qualify for colllege or not.

36659804
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

What has the Board done right? said on Thursday, Jan 28 at 10:45 PM

Uh thats family lifetime medical. Anyway, name one success of this board the past year. All negative successes like firing Lal, dumping Kaplan, both after wasting millions of dollars they did not have.Now they want to water down the high school curriculum to increase the graduation rate. Parents, your school board thinks your child is flat out dumb and can't graduate from regular courses! Go to the Board Meetings and hear it yourself!

36584192
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To support said on Thursday, Jan 28 at 10:36 PM

Do you know what lifetime medical is worth? You are nuts.

36583902
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WHAT! said on Thursday, Jan 28 at 2:00 PM

To support the board-- Please post another paragragh after you go to the toilet and get all the sh-- out of you!

36555059
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

To Support said on Thursday, Jan 28 at 7:26 AM

What planet do you live on?

36523402
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Support the Board said on Wednesday, Jan 27 at 10:16 PM

The Board has done a commendable jobl They fired Lal, forced Silverio to resign and they work for very little money. All they get is free lifetime medical benefits and a small salary! They have given us lots of new schools and our graduates go to excellent universities. All this bickering because a couple of teachers are going to be dropped. There is too much dead wood anyway. Great job school board, you got reelected too. Lynwood parents know what is really going on.

36507632
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

LTA Member said on Wednesday, Jan 27 at 9:39 PM

I think it is time to recall Marquez, he is just a puppet who will bend over and sell the union members out for a District or CTA position. Teachers are having meetings this month to talk to other unions to represent us, the info will be coming soon.

36506239
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Firebaugh teacher said on Tuesday, Jan 26 at 12:30 AM

"Money is the Mother's Milk of Politics" - J. Unhrah. Thats never been truer than in Lynwood. Where did the money go? FCMAT says misspent, mismanaged and misused. Yet the Lynwood Unified Bureaucracy is all still in the District Office. They could have saved money by closing a couple of schools, but they missed the deadline and now will lay off even more teachers, aides, and custodians than would have been needed. Simply not up to doing their job.

36367737
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Saturday, Jan 23 at 6:23 PM

There is so much to change. Where do we start? I picketed outside the polling place only to see Lynwood residents vote corruption back in.I will always give the children my best,but it's hard to watch people lose jobs, and take pay cuts,and it's totally out of your contrill. What we need is a miracle!

36223667
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

x said on Saturday, Jan 23 at 5:51 PM

So true... the last post is correct... WE have seen too much.Its time for a change.

36222504
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

to The Children said on Tuesday, Jan 19 at 2:48 AM

As a once optimistic teacher, it saddens me to see the state the district is in.I agree with 'The Children'.Students do not seem to be the focus when THEY are the reason we are all working hard. So many teachers feel disappointed by this district. Its enough to make teachers want to find a different district to work for.Come on Lynwood,we need to clean up this mess for the children.We need to give them the skills to move upward and onward but we are too busy thinking about our own personal gain.

35896094
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

The Children? said on Sunday, Jan 17 at 5:18 PM

The children come in last in Lynwood. I am convinced of that after 20 years in this community! #1 is politics. #2 personal vendettas. #3 what's in it for me! etc. #100 what is best for children!

35815594
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Questions said on Sunday, Jan 17 at 10:19 AM

Who, when, what, where and how were actual dollars misspent, misused or misappropriated? Who will be held accountable and made to answer these questions? Stop the cover-up. What about the children?

35797334
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

so important said on Saturday, Jan 16 at 5:21 PM

Lynwood resideents, please read paragraph 16 carefully! Stop voting the same wrong-doers back in to office. What are you thinking? Lynwood you had an opportunity to make a change, and you did nothing. God help your city and you ignorance.

35770307
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Don't be Shocked said on Thursday, Jan 7 at 9:44 PM

Anonymous is correct about being shocked. Racism has kept LUSD from becoming a truly fine district. Always lawsuits & retribution instead of working together in a friendly, collegial atmosphere. It starts at the top and is all pervasive. State takeover is not the answer, cleaning house is! Sell properties, get rid of goofy attendance boundaries, cut district office administration to % of budget amounts shown at well run districts! It must be done!

35111969
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

sk2 said on Thursday, Jan 7 at 11:09 AM

No melt pot...salad bowl. Once again, this community has to get its school district taken over by the state. This is to end up the corruption that they bring in to the US.

35069001
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Jan 6 at 8:09 PM

"Plaza Mexico School District"? "Burrito-eater community"? I am shocked at the racism being slung around in the comments section. Kettle meet pot. Shame on you all!

35029334
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Wednesday, Jan 6 at 10:45 AM

We are going down slowly and the fall can't be stopped!!!!!!!!!!!! We have lost here in Lynwood but the parents and students have lost particularly!!!!!

34990599
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Concerned Teacher said on Tuesday, Jan 5 at 11:34 AM

Why are we getting rid of our best principals and keeping the worst ones- Mrs. Gould (Washington Elementary) WHY?

34927384
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Tuesday, Jan 5 at 8:17 AM

THIS SCHOOL DISTRICT SHOULD NOW BE CALLED PLAZA MEXICO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT. WHERE IS THE STATE? HURRY UP

34913389
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Tuesday, Jan 5 at 7:46 AM

Supposedly Saunder Dillon who is currently in Ms. Coffey’s place will be opening two new positions? How? They don’t have a health tech or librarian right now for and HELLO, we are in a financial crisis! Maybe the State’s take over would do Lynwood some good.

34911512
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Tuesday, Jan 5 at 7:46 AM

Supposedly Saunder Dillon who is currently in Ms. Coffey’s place will be opening two new positions? How? They don’t have a health tech or librarian right now for and HELLO, we are in a financial crisis! Maybe the State’s take over would do Lynwood some good.

34911501
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Lynwood Resident and Parent said on Tuesday, Jan 5 at 7:43 AM

And the saga continues! Ms. Coffey from Rosa Parks was reassigned on a “special assignment” because she refused to play politics. Allegedly, Maria Lopez’s niece’s son is a bully and was asked to go back to his home school as a result of his continuous negative behavior. Why was she reprimanded for doing the right thing? I applaud Ms. Coffey!! We want her back at Rosa Parks, she does her job well and is a straight arrow. It seems that nothing has changed except for the players.

34911292
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Things are bleak said on Monday, Jan 4 at 9:16 PM

Woe is us in L US D. Other than Lal, any other administrators heads gonna roll? We are still waitin. We are spent into a $50,000,000 hole and lets see if I understand this, the School Board isn't at fault, the administrators aren't at fault including the LAL buddies like Bill, Sally, Zim, Kevin. Then who is at fault? The voters? The county? Who should be fired for this? Is it all Lal fault only? Why we paying him $30,000 per month to sip Mai Tai in Tahiti?

34893574
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

sk said on Monday, Jan 4 at 11:17 AM

At this point, I think we'll be better off taken over by the state. This burrito-eater community voted to continue the corruption as it is a good reflection of what's going on in their 4th world countries.

34860269
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

anonymous said on Sunday, Jan 3 at 5:28 PM

We are counting on the school board to clean house at the top where the mismanagement of funds occurred. If you don't, the state will do the job for you.

34817169
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Latin Mavin said on Saturday, Jan 2 at 11:21 PM

Ms. Santana knows that the three wonder boys supported Lal to the end. It took community, teachers and employees to rid Lynwood of this curse!! breaking cur

34785949
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

see below said on Saturday, Jan 2 at 8:07 PM

continues. We need sharp,intelligent,fiscally trained, business minded,people of integrity to navigate us out of this terrible plight.May God send the guidance we need.

34779657
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

from the top down said on Saturday, Jan 2 at 7:53 PM

Sure Lal maybe horrible for taking this district to the poor house,but I don't blame him. The board and the fiscal managers are to blame.They allowed Lal to runamuck because they tusted him to be on the up and up. They (the board) are so incompetent,they believed in Lal to lead, instead of leading as they were elected to do. But stupid Lynwood residents re-elected them back again. The same pitiful board is in control. I hope all the consultants they hire are morally sound,otherwisethe saga just

34779212
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

sleazy said on Saturday, Jan 2 at 3:44 PM

It looks like Island Boy can now BUY an island...Hey Board, if the next potential Supt. comes in with a private law firm to negotiate their contract...Run. This is public ed. not some fortune 500 company. If Lal has a shred of decency He would give this money back...

34772186
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Question? said on Saturday, Jan 2 at 9:02 AM

Are you sure the former supt. is being paid $17,000 instead of $31,000 a month?

34759789
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Back This Train Up A Minute said on Friday, Jan 1 at 2:19 AM

Ms. Santana, you do a great job recapping the many horrors of the LUSD. However, somehow in this district, teachers are always made the fall guys, and your piece is representative of this. "Years of saving teachers' jobs while other districts were making...cuts" cannot be blamed for the terrible predicament this district is in. The cause can be laid at the feet of the brainless, self-serving criminals who have populated the Superintendent, School Board, and school administration positions.

34716139
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

x said on Thursday, Dec 31 at 2:13 PM

$17,000 a month for a man who helped ruin a school district. How can board members show their faces in Lynwood and how much longer can this community remain silent and not get the media coverage it desperately needs! Keep digging Wave...

34696924
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Thursday, Dec 31 at 9:03 AM

WOW

34681251
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

Los Angeles Wave and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

ON DEMAND

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.