Prosecutor says son killed mom because she wanted him to become a doctor

By WIRE SERVICES

Tools

SANTA ANA -- A Garden Grove man of Vietnamese descent got so angry at his 71-year-old mother for nagging him to become a doctor that he choked her, causing her to have a fatal heart attack, a prosecutor told jurors Thursday.

Son Richard Lam Nguyen, 31, is on trial for the murder of his mother, Nuong Nguyen, on Dec. 20, 2008.

His attorney, Rob Harley told the jury he is not guilty of murder because he choked his mother in the "heat of the moment,'' and that her death was an "accident'' not caused by choking.

Son Nguyen had a close relationship with his mother, who paid for his schooling until the night of her death, when she gave him an "ultimatum,'' as Nguyen told police, to become a doctor instead of a pharmacist.

The argument "escalated'' as Son Nguyen said it made more sense to finish the last year of school he needed to become a pharmacist instead of the six years he would need to become a doctor, Harley said.

Nuong Nguyen said he would shame the family if he were to be a pharmacist and cause her to "lose face'' with her best friend whose two sons were doctors, Harley said.

Since it was rare for the two to argue, the confrontation shocked the son into "going ballistic,'' and he choked her for six to seven seconds, Harley said.

Son Nguyen ran out of the house, with his mother still gasping for breath, and drove around for a few hours until he fell asleep, Harley said. At some point, he grew worried that his sickly mother, who needed dialysis for a bad kidney and suffered from anemia and a weak heart among many other ailments, may have died, Harley said.

When Son Nguyen arrived home, he found his mother dead, called police and told investigators what happened.

Deputy District Attorney Cameron Talley played portions of a video in which Son Gguyen calmly told an investigator about the dispute with his mother and how he choked her.

"She just kept nagging, and I turned around and put my hands on her neck and squeezed real hard for six or seven seconds,'' he said and acknowledged that what he did was "illegal.''

Talley said the evidence will show Son Nguyen choked his 5-foot, 80- pound mother with such force that it broke the vertebrae in her neck and some thyroid cartilage.

"He took his hands, put them around her frail, wrinkly throat and squeezed really, really hard,'' Talley said.

He asserted the choking triggered a fatal heart attack.

Talley acknowledged that Son Nguyen has a history of mental illness, but noted he was prescribed drugs that helped him earn a degree in biology from UC Irvine and go on to a pharmaceutical school in Massachusetts and medical school at Ross University in the Caribbean country of Dominica.

Son Nguyen had no other mental health issues until January, when he was about to go on trial for murder, Talley said.

Harley said the case is "about a mother's lifelong obsession with having a doctor for a son,'' Harley said.

He said mother and son had a close but "dysfunctional'' and "co- dependent'' relationship, and that she told Son Nguyen to spy on his father when she suspected he was having an affair. They later divorced.

Confrontations with his father led to Son Nguyen being hospitalized for his psychological problems, Harley said.

Harley said he intends to show how Vietnamese cultural issues played a part in his mother's badgering her son about his career choices. He said it is not uncommon for some Vietnamese parents to pick a career for their children and then expect them to follow through or face humiliating shame.

Son Nguyen suffered from schizophrenia, anxiety and depression and his mother "was a heart attack waiting to happen,'' he said.

"He was constantly dealing with the fear of not living up to his mother's expectations,'' Harley added.

The two lived together in a rented room in Garden Grove, and Son Nguyen had to take a year off from school because her medical issues had drained their finances, Harley said.

Son Nguyen thought it was more practical to do one more year of school and get a job as a pharmacist to help his mother with her medical bills, Harley said.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

RLane said on Saturday, Aug 13 at 12:50 PM

Also, the side effects of those drugs for his pychological problems is partly to blame. Side effects of those drugs include suicide, extreme anger, depression etc.

72301548
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

MakoSharkEsq said on Saturday, Jul 3 at 11:39 AM

What every comment below is doing is appraising the defendant. You're not St. Peter. That's not the task of a juror. A defendant's guilt or non-guilt isn't based on whether you ~empathize~ or "like" the defendant or based on the defendant's "character" or "worth." It's whether the facts of the case match the elements of the crime. A jury should NEVER consider the extent of punishment as a factor in establishing guilt or non-guilt. All you're supposed to do is answer whether he did it or not.

46740103
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Christine Tran said on Friday, Apr 30 at 10:32 PM

Son is a victim of a unique circumstance. Locking him behind bars does not help or heal but hurt ! Please give him a chance to start his "own" life.

42352831
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

bob nguyen said on Monday, Apr 26 at 10:10 PM

Personally, I think Son Nguyen should be getting a death sentence. And this is a wake up call for all Vietnamese Americans who think they too Americanized and trying to apply American's values, and morals on their parents. Heck, you should know that you can't change your parents the way of life over night since Confucius has been has deeply influenced your parents thought and life. It just a matter of time to change them but not now though

42049789
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

nameless said on Saturday, Apr 24 at 7:56 PM

As a vietnamese american, it is very very common to see children pressured to the point of suicide over education. Whether it be lawyer, engineer, or doctor, it is extremely common. He killed his own mother and his regret and the trauma he'll have to endure for the rest of his life will be a greater punishment that what any jail cell or death penalty can offer. He came back and he's facing the consequences instead of running away. Hopefully they'll take it lightly on him.

41937872
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

L Nguyen said on Friday, Apr 23 at 12:13 AM

One has to be in Son's plight to understand the tremendous pressure to achieve that he faced, which led him to be insane to kill his mother. Please take it under consideration to pardon him.

41811074
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Paul Le said on Thursday, Apr 22 at 4:51 PM

Please reduce the time in prison dor Son Nguyen.

41790256
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

T. Ha said on Thursday, Apr 22 at 4:18 PM

Son is just a victim from a broken family with a Mother who was pushing him to hard. He suffers enough, please give him a second chance.

41788549
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

No Name said on Friday, Apr 16 at 11:43 AM

This is an tragic accident when he under his mother pressured. Hope the judge will consider his case to help him to get back his life.

41409129
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Peter Trinh (HopeToday) said on Friday, Apr 16 at 6:03 AM

Undeniable with push and shove psychologically and physically at the end. It is really a tragic accident waiting to happen among any Asian Family, not just the Vietnamese. Nobody is in the win-win position here!!! Hope the judge will hand down a lighter sentence in early to mid May, 2010 so that this young man can rebuilt his life.

41381339
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

C Ngo said on Wednesday, Apr 14 at 3:29 PM

He, son , needs to be forgive by the people because his mother was unreasonable to her expectation. She needed to let him growth. She put him to hard, so now she destroyed her son life and hers.

41275792
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

Los Angeles Wave and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

On Demand

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.