At this summer session in Watts, Black students need not apply

Bottom Line

Tools

By BETTY PLEASANT, Contributing Editor

Some parents, teachers and staff are seething at John Ritter Elementary School in Watts over a situation not seen since the U.S. Supreme Court issued its 1954 landmark Brown vs. Board of Education decision integrating the country’s public schools.

But here it is, 2009, and some people see the shadow of Jim Crow looming over Watts and they’re mad about it. Why? Because Ritter — a public school — began a summer session for its students Monday in which all the subject matter is taught in Spanish. No child who does not speak Spanish (read: no Black child) is in it.

This separate thing at Ritter is far from being equal because the Los Angeles Unified School District has canceled summer school this year for all of its elementary and middle school children, so no child speaking any language is receiving summer school instruction, except at Ritter.

You see, Ritter is one of Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s 10 Partnership for Los Angeles Schools that he runs with private funds he’s obtained from somewhere. Ritter is in Villaraigosa’s “school district.” The LAUSD has no real control over the mayor’s schools and, in fact, did not even know that Ritter was providing a summer school of any kind — let alone a segregated kind — until I told them and provided the documents to prove it.

Charlene Green, principal of Ritter, wrote a June 23 letter to the school’s parents (in Spanish and English) announcing the July 6 start of a Spanish language arts summer program at the school that would take place from 8 a.m. to 12:30 p.m. each weekday for four weeks.

In her letter, Green advises that enrollment in the program would be on a first-come, first-served basis, and she stressed, in underlined, boldface type that: “This summer program will strictly focus on Spanish language arts. There will be NO (the capitalization is Green’s) English language development or English language arts component during this session. All subject matter will be taught in Spanish.”

Ritter teachers told me they were aghast by this and spoke against it in a meeting when they were informed of it. “Are you serious?” they asked. “It’s ridiculous!” they declared upon realizing the Villaraigosa School District was, indeed, serious. I was told that one of the teachers was really angry and raged: “My kids are low-performing too and they need all the help they can get! Why is it that only Spanish-speaking kids can get extra help?”

I called Green for an interview about her letter, wanting to know more about the program and specifically what subject matter would the program cover only in Spanish. Green would not let me ask a single question about her letter, as she cut me off with a firm “no comment,” like she’s a movie star and not the head of what purports to be a public school.

I did, however, had a lengthy interview with Marshall Tuck, the CEO of Villaraigosa’s Partnership for Los Angeles Schools organization. He explained that the four-week, Spanish-speaking only summer school at Ritter resulted from the suspension a few months ago of the Dual Language Immersion Program at Ritter in which instruction was provided in both English and Spanish. He said Ritter’s program, which had operated for several years, was closed because of its “low quality.”

Even though it had poor outcomes, Tuck said the parents of some of the dual language students were very upset about the closure of the program and wanted their children to continue to be taught in Spanish. “The Partnership agreed to do something for these families, so we offered those kids who had been in the defunct dual language program an alternative,” Tuck said.

“The parents felt they were wronged by the closure of the dual language program, so we committed to offer some Saturday classes and a short summer program this year only at Ritter for 40 students who were in the old dual language program.

“The plans for the summer program were in place before the LAUSD canceled summer school throughout the district,” Tuck continued. “We did not anticipate that we would be providing the only summer instruction in the city, but we had made a commitment to some very upset parents and we feel obligated to fulfill it.”

Be that as it may, he’s created even more upset parents, one of whom said to me: “If you can’t have [a summer session] for all the students, why have it at all? I don’t think that’s right. They appease one group and offend another.”

A Ritter employee, who requested anonymity because they are not allowed to talk to the media, said this Spanish-language summer school adversely impacts not only Black students, but Black staff members, as well. “Blacks who normally work here are off for the summer. Black teachers, teachers’ aides and office staff wanted to work the month the school is open, but they were told they couldn’t work their usual jobs and all of them have been replaced by Hispanics.

“Morale is really low around here,” the employee continued. “The people with this partnership money believe they can do anything they want — and they do. First they give them Saturday school and now summer school and Black people’s jobs, so what’s next?”

I can think of several things that could be next: How about a lawsuit extending Brown vs. Board of Education to privately funded educational activities conducted on public property? How about making mayors and others with private funds establish private schools in which they can mete out preferential treatment to their hearts’ content? How about having one unified public school district in control of all the public schools? How about letting educators run the public schools and politicians run something else? How about …

Tuesday, Sep 1 at 10:12 AM Ask Why! wrote ...

Have you ever asked yourself why there is a need to teach so many classes in Spanish in the first place? How much does it all cost? Where else could that money be spent? It's also big business.

28584486
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 23 at 8:12 AM Alan Pretorius wrote ...

What happened to America as the 'melting pot' we were all proud of? No more melting going on now. We're having Spanish rammed down our throats by the liberal teachers union and politicians who support them.

26623157
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 22 at 10:13 AM CaliMex wrote ...

In Mexico, public school instruction is in SPANISH; English language is a subject of instruction in some of the schools. There are no special considerations given for non-Spanish speaking students. It is instant immersion. The official language of Mexico is Spanish. Government offices are not obligated to provide translation; legal documents must be in Spanish language to be enforced. Makes sense to me. How and why did we become so "compassionate" ?

26567757
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jul 21 at 4:44 PM Lynn wrote ...

As a LAUSD teacher, I'm appalled, but not surprised. The schools with the most Spanish-speaking, lowest performing students get the most money. Sad!

26526209
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jul 21 at 4:00 PM Carol wrote ...

I fully understand that the spanish language arts program has been offered to assist all children to become biligual. However, offering a Language Arts program would have covered both spanish and english. Our children must be competent in english...many jobs, schools, and tests still require a comprehensive knowledge of english and its mechanics. What good is speaking perfect spanish if the children can't communicate in the primary global language which happens to be english?

26523914
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jul 21 at 9:09 AM WTF? wrote ...

This is not journalism. Do not get it twisted. This is a clearly biased piece from the very beginning.

26497157
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jul 20 at 7:39 AM margaret wrote ...

suit should be pursued. The taxpayers let these people do what they want, we pay for it and still we have to go back when wrong things happen and pay for it again, i.e. with the lawsuits that it ends up causing. when is this city going to learn?

26406169
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 19 at 11:17 AM Tell the truth wrote ...

Can anybody associated with the Mayors Partnership just tell the truth? We can't TRUST anything you say at this point! We will all have to wait until August 25, 2009.

26368034
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jul 18 at 9:16 PM not curious anymore wrote ...

"All of the students (K-3) who participated in the Dual Language Program in the 2007-08 school year are welcome to participate in the summer program, which included Latino and African-American students." Quote from Angela Bass, Superintendent of Instruction. The only story here is that someone with incomplete information (perhaps the person in room 32 at 1:00 pm) immediately jumped to the worst conclusion they could reach and contacted the media. People, black and brown need to work TOGETHER

26344444
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Saturday, Jul 18 at 7:34 PM Tarreel wrote ...

Black students need not apply? Why? There are people here from Belize and other Latin countries who speak Spanish as well. You failed on trying to cause some sort of outrage. Maybe you should take you bigot little self to a LA community college and see how many Blacks speak Spanish. You failed.

26341467
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 17 at 8:50 PM osirassun wrote ...

HELLO! I don't care if the article is inaccurate. This problems is a fact and it has been happening for a very long time. An some of you fine folks have been ignoring it. Just a few samples so you can understand that you have a problem HOUSTON! Illegal Alien Invasion Deadlier Than Iraqhttp://www.humanevents.com/article.php?id=10663

26297721
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 17 at 8:49 PM osirassun wrote ...

Teen Girl Shot In Racially Motivated Hate Crime http://cbs2.com/local/girl.racially.motivated.2.526064.html Execution of black students by illegal alien http://www.alipac.us/modules.php?name=News&file=article&sid=2459

26297681
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 17 at 8:47 PM osirassun wrote ...

Jamiel Shaw http://web.mac.com/waltermoore/WalterMooreForMayor/Jamiels_Law.html ntonio Villaraigosa RASCIST LOS ANGELES MAYOR http://www.mayorno.com/Villaraigosa.html HAWAIIAN GARDENS GANG INVOLVED IN MURDER OF SHERIFF’S DEPUTY, ATTACKS ON AFRICAN-AMERICANS AND WIDESPREAD DRUG TRAFFICKING http://www.usdoj.gov/usao/cac/pressroom/pr2009/065.html THE TOWN THE LAW FORGOT http://www.laweekly.com/2007-02-22/news/the-town-the-law-forgot/

26297632
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 17 at 3:55 PM the truth hurts wrote ...

Unless you were at John Ritter Elementary June 19, 2009 at 1:00pm room 32. All of you would have heard Marshall Tuck stated to the staff. That the summer school will not be for all students it will only be for spanish learns. Don't get mad at Ms. Pleasant for exposing the truth and being fair and objective.Fact: Their are no black student attending summer school or black staff working.Why should not the Black community feel violated?

26286369
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 17 at 9:18 AM Walter Moore wrote ...

Betty Pleasant, you ROCK! This is an important story, and you're the only one to spot it! The L.A. Times and local TV stations should be all over this. Thank you for telling us about this obscene misuse of tax dollars.

26263072
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 16 at 9:19 PM curious wrote ...

Dual immersion is a type of bilingual program where both the dominant and non-dominant language speakers are mixed together to learn from each other. Is Ms. Pleasant saying that English (dominant) speakers were prohibited from taking the class? If so, then this cannot be called dual immersion. It would be "language arts in the primary language."I suspect English speakers were invited but chose not take advantage of this valuable opportunity, as mentioned by Ritter employees above.

26235241
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 16 at 1:18 PM Useless Tripe I Write (B. Pleasant) wrote ...

So much for objectivity in one's piece of work...this is no more than a step up from an asinine blog post. Betty has an agenda and reaches for evidence (in her opinion) to support that agenda. I can almost hear the anger in your voice Betty, after every sentence, I'm sure you utter below your breath, "F-ing webacks."

26212539
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 16 at 8:35 AM Pro partnership!! wrote ...

The partnership (including Green, Tuck, & the Mayor) have made some positive changes at Ritter within only ten months! Those who criticize them have obviously never been to Ritter! If you really cared about this community, which you don't, because you don't have anything but racist comments and unsubstantiated fact to go on, you would see that Green and Tuck have both been hands on in developing better teacher trainings and creating intervention prog after school 4 ALL students!

26191599
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 10:20 PM Melisma wrote ...

Institutionalize segregation in America should never take place. This is a english speaking country. Our schools should never cater to foreign speaking people over Americans. Our schools bend over backwards with American tax dollars to teach foreigners english as a second language. Yet, our children get excluded in our American schools because they don't speak spanish. Our Latin Mayor can go to hell! He lacks morals and seriously lacks any common sense. He needs to be voted out!

26165554
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 8:56 PM Clay Bolt wrote ...

No matter what side you're on, you gotta admit: something fishy is going on in the LAUSD. And when it comes to education, 2 groups have ALL the power: teacher's unions and the politicians who cater to them. Although both groups may claim differently, neither one does anything "for the children". Those days are gone! They do it for personal gain and political power. Based upon results, I'd say those kids who got left out this summer are the winners!

26162961
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 5:04 PM Do Your Homework Betty Part 2 wrote ...

As far as African Americans losing their jobs..that is a flat out a lie. Ritter has never hosted summer school sessions on campus. So I dont know what this anonymous Ritter employee is talking about. The teachers selected to teach these summer classes have the required credential to teach Spanish. A teacher without this credential cannot teach a Spanish class. That is a fact Betty. All teachers were given the opportunity to sign up to teach. NO African American employees were replaced!

26152749
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 4:55 PM Do Your Homework Betty! wrote ...

I am in shock how Betty Pleasant can write such an article full of statements not backed up by facts. Maybe this is why she works for the WAVE and not a major newspaper like the Times or Daily News. This summer school was offered to ALL students, Latinos and African Americans. Parents were sent notices to see how many parents were interested in Spanish language arts. These classes were open to all students, even if they weren't previously enrolled in the Dual language program.

26152384
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 11:53 AM Even more concerned! wrote ...

HELLO! Is anybody out there from the Ritter community! This whole article is inaccurate and essentially a lie! I have been on the campus and there are African American employees on campus this summer. One of which includes the principal. Anyways, believe what you want, but SERIOUSLY at least try getting the facts staright! These types of articles are what give my community bad rap. A black family member of mine was invited to join and our family chose not to participate! Blacks were included!

26132349
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 11:45 AM WTF!? wrote ...

Does anyone other than the disgruntled employee know what the make-up is of these classes? I find it quite appauling that the first thing that readers think of is how learning spanish is equivalent to illegal immigrants! WTF! are you kidding. Any educated person understands that learning any second language, is vital to a child's life long educational career! Apparently none of the readers do. Guarantee, however that every affluent community in LA does understand this!

26131617
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 11:13 AM community member wrote ...

Wow! Ms. Pleasant I wonder have you ever stepped foot onto Ritter ES? As a community member of over 15 years, I can atest to the diverse faculty, students, parents, and stakeholders who have given extreme amounts of time and energy into making this school, that has been neglected by LAUSD and the community for so long, a school that in the last few years has increased state test scores by almost 60 points for ALL students. Where was the publicity for this school then? This article is slanderous!

26128887
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 10:14 AM Concerned Citizen wrote ...

Marshall Tuck's never been a teacher. He went to the Harvard School of Business and has been hired to run the schools as a business. This means that someone somewhere is financially benefitting from this situation, regardless of what the outcome is, or who feels insulted. He cares about no one! He cares about running schools like a business and making sure that the schools somehow turn a profit regardless of who gets trampled in process. People like Marshall Tuck need to get out of

26124844
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 10:12 AM Concerned Citizen wrote ...

Ever met the Mayor and Marshall Tuck in person? The Mayor has no idea what goes on in “his” schools. I am sure that he too found out about this situation reading this or some other article. Really!! He is that clueless. The one who is getting a kick out of this is Marshall Tuck. This is his doing...he enjoys setting minority groups against each other.

26124702
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Wednesday, Jul 15 at 9:23 AM teacher wrote ...

Betty... you better get all of your facts straight. These accuasations are not only false... but scarring to say the least to the INTEGRITY of our name. What teachers have you asked? NONE! The National Enquirer does this kind of propaganda. This Paper should be ASHAMED for printing this and not getting to the heart of the matter, the truth. BTW, your source? Came from a disgruntled employee of the school (who has little or no tact/integrity). SHAME ON YOU.

26120947
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jul 14 at 8:06 PM nazysc wrote ...

If LAUSD and Antonio would take care of there business these racist attacks children would never happen. Please read the comments. Pitting two groups against each other has always been used to keep people in poverty.

26084526
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Tuesday, Jul 14 at 2:49 PM Charles wrote ...

I'm not surprised this racist activitiy is happening in California. Someone needs to sue that racist mayor and find out who his donors are. California has been destroyed by the illegal alien invasion. That state is broke and illegal immigration and high taxes has caused it. California is the future of this country if our spineless government doesn't stop it.

26068797
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jul 13 at 2:49 PM Bobby wrote ...

It doesn't matter how "HARD WORKING" illegal aliens are. I know tons of "hard working" Americans. They don't belong here. Their nation is Mexico. They are border criminals, the same as border criminals who enter Mexico illegally. The difference is, Mexico deals with it, while OUR CORRUPT LEADERS DO NOT.

25988876
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jul 13 at 2:21 PM Frankfacts wrote ...

I don't blame the illegal aliens from Mexico. The vast majority are good decent hard-working people wanting a better life. (Believe it or not, but also LEGALLY.) I blame the succession of corrupt, racist, incompetant government leaders and officials in Mexico City, and the top U.S. government officials who are in collusion with this evil. The N.A.A.C.P. and L.U.L.A.C. can force positive quick change in Mexico, if we would only get rid of our incompetant opportunistic leaders.

25987289
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Monday, Jul 13 at 12:29 PM The Redskin Redneck wrote ...

While waiting for Ramon Herrera's reply, I can only comment on his statement as to how many people speak Spanish in the U.S., that millions of them are here illegally. When they are deported, than the U.S. won't be the 3rd most Spanish speaking nation. Will it? A little detail Mr. Herrera would want Americans to overlook.

25979636
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 11:35 PM The Redskin Redneck wrote ...

Ramon F. Herrera, since you seem to be a judge of ignorance, I'll give you some proof of your own--(ignorance). Spanish is a low level language, among the worlds languages. It has neither produced any great literature, nor is it an international language in the business sense. The same can be said for science and medicine. English is the business language of the world, in spite of the polite Japanese business mans answer to you. Millions of people illegally in this nation speak it. So what?

25937151
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 8:55 PM Ramon F Herrera wrote ...

[Redneck:] "What the hell is so important about Spanish???" It is the most spoken language of the Western hemisphere. The US is the 3rd. country in the world where more people speak Spanish. An American executive challenged a Japanese colleague: "Which is the international language of business?". The Japanese promptly replied: "The language of my customer". It is OK being ignorant, but it is not being proud of it.

25933139
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 8:33 PM Ramon F Herrera wrote ...

In addition to being a language, Spanish is an educational subject. This case is the same as requiring math proficiency. In that case Betty wouldn't complain that they are discriminating against non-math-geeks.

25932351
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 8:19 PM Maria wrote ...

What's new?all racists illegal aliens are invading this country and now is becoming Mexifornia nasty corrupted as they're country!! Sue this lady and villaraigoza!!

25931809
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 5:37 PM The Redskin Redneck wrote ...

If that school receives one single cent of Federal or State money, the principal and all those involved need to be busted!! No more sucking up to La Raza and other hispanic racist ethnic interest groups. What the hell is so important about Spanish???

25924949
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 4:56 PM Osirassun wrote ...

We had a chance to replace Villaraigosa with Walter Moore but you folks keep voting for these clowns. May be next time you'll vote for the correct candidate. Boycott any and all things from mexico. Stop paying for your own overthrow.

25923136
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 4:20 PM Osirassun wrote ...

Are you awake yet America? can you see what's happening ? Do you know what to do about this issue? 1 877-823-6535 It's time to fix things NOW!

25921612
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 4:06 PM Bobby wrote ...

Obviously Ms. Charlene Green, cut off the reporter of this story-- because she knows she can't answer any of Ms. Pleasants questions, legitimately. So she does what every other cowardly beurocrat does--hide, clam up, etc. Remember, though, there is no reconquista, etc.

25921051
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 4:00 PM The Redskin Redneck wrote ...

..and all of them(blacks) have been replaced by hispanics." THERE IS NO RECONQUISTA! Oh well, it just amuses me to no end, how Sheila Jackson Lee, Jesse Jackson, Al Sharpton, Earl Ofari Hutchison, and other influential black liberals, are STONE DEAF TO IT ALL. They're still fighting the civil rights movement of the sixties. Talk about clueless to the core!!

25920782
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 2:52 PM BlackCats in Ontario wrote ...

This is certainly an appalling news. The good news is that my good friend of mine is running for governor. Her name is Chelene Nightingale, and if elected, she will vastly improved the State's eduction. She will also offer parents many options for the kids to obtain education. She is a strong supporter of homeschooling and she is against on having classroom being taught in Spanish, while English speaking kids are stuck. Go to www.nightingaleforgovernor.com for more information. Thank you!

25917709
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Sunday, Jul 12 at 2:41 PM Bobby wrote ...

I have watched these long time Californians who are so shocked at what has happened to their state because of the illegal alien invasion from Mexico. They sit, comfortably, in their living rooms, watching the illegal aliens cut mow lawn, trim their trees, and clean their pools. They want it both ways.Then there are the other ner-do-well Californians, who live in secluded beach areas, and gated communities, who also use illegal aliens, and don't mind at all-as long as they don't live there. Wimps

25917241
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 10 at 8:23 PM SOULMAN wrote ...

This is typical and more is yet to come . Next there will be charter schools run by Green Dot and you need not show up because you will not be the flavor of the month, either. The community and parents need to become more involved and organized in this effort.

25827819
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 10 at 2:57 PM AmericanAge wrote ...

This article by Ms. Pleasant is simply superb! This is the kind of journalism that needs national coverage and Ms. Pleasant was able to capture that point of view. Personally it pains me to see that this rubbish is happening in this day and age. I am sure that Ritter receives federal monies and as such the Mayor is certainly in in violation of the 14th Amendment.

25813277
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Friday, Jul 10 at 8:22 AM Bookie CPT wrote ...

this is the only country where citizens have to change their lives and the way they go about life because of illegals why must we learn spanish when this is cali they need to lear english if they want to live here

25786464
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 9 at 6:07 PM ANTHONY wrote ...

No justice, No Peace!! This type of blatant discrimination will be the spark for the "next" riot in the L.A. We as blacks are in another fight...dig in!

25750814
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Thursday, Jul 9 at 2:21 PM Tigress wrote ...

If I were parent at school site I would sue the school. Because what your doing, your separating colors and raises. We all grew up in Watts that we were one it doesn't matter what color. New staff is making everything go wrong for school and commnunity. You should be ashamed of yourself. How dare you let go of all black employee that were there when we were in school and and our kids are in school. who are you to come in separated us like that? You need to shoot yourself in a head. Watts was 1

25736612
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

Los Angeles Wave | Los Angeles News and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

More Good Stuff

Advertisement

ON DEMAND

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.