Bottom Line: Politicians and activists demand equal education on Watts campus

By BETTY PLEASANT, Contributing Editor

Tools

As the result of last week’s column on the “Spanish only” summer program at John Ritter Elementary School, LAUSD board member Marguerite LaMotte presented a motion at Tuesday’s board meeting calling for access and equity for all students in the school district.

The motion, which was co-authored by board members Richard Vladovic and Steven Zimmer, specifically addresses the revelation that a four-week summer school session for Spanish-speaking students only is under way at the Watts-area Ritter School while no summer instruction is being provided to English-speaking students.

The Ritter School is one of Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa’s Partnership for Los Angeles schools — a group of 10 public schools carved out of the LAUSD system and given to the mayor to operate.

A furor has erupted in the city’s non-Spanish speaking population over Ritter’s special summer class, especially in light of the fact that no elementary and middle school summer classes are being provided for public school children anywhere else in the district, as they were all canceled because of the district’s catastrophic shortage of funds.

The Rev. Eric Lee, executive director of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference-Los Angeles, was livid when he learned of Ritter’s Spanish-only summer school, and vowed: “We’re going to do something about this.” He said he spoke with Marshall Tuck, the CEO of the mayor’s Partnership Schools system, and listened to his explanations for the program.

“It still doesn’t make any sense to me,” Lee said. “If they were committed to have a Spanish-language instruction program, then they should have at least had an English-language instruction program as well.”

Lee, along with Adrian Dove, head of the California Congress of Racial Equality, met with the Black Education Task Force on the issue Monday and Lee said the group is demanding that Partnership Schools amass enough resources to have an English-language summer school at Ritter.

The National Association for Equal Justice in America (NAEJA) is scheduled to take up the Ritter summer school issue at its membership meeting Saturday, and the Urban Roundtable has issued a scathing indictment of the separate, but in-no-way equal, educational activity under way at Ritter and has vowed to fight it.

Ramon Cortines, superintendent of the LAUSD, said Monday that he and his district have no jurisdiction over the mayor’s Partnership Schools and, consequently, are not in the loop about anything they do. “But I want to make it plain that I never have believed and do not now believe in ‘separate but equal’ anything — certainly not a separate education,” Cortines said.

LaMotte, the only African-American on the LAUSD school board, angrily denounced the goings-on at Ritter.

“The Partnership Schools are still district-owned schools and are subject to all laws and policies of all district schools,” LaMotte said. “It is unacceptable and unconscionable that this has occurred in an LAUSD school. Although Partnership Schools have greater flexibility in their operation, this does not give them the right to discriminate in any way, and I personally, apologize to the students and parents who were denied access and appeal to the district and the Partnership to publicly do the same."

As to the LaMotte/Vladovic/Zimmer motion, it reads as follows:

“Whereas the alleged incident at an LAUSD IDesign Partnership School and other incidents have brought to light the disturbing reality that racism and social injustice continue to exist in the educational community, as well as the community at large; and

“Whereas, the Equal Protection clause of the U.S. Constitution, the Civil Rights Act of 1964 and state doctrines, such as the California Constitution demand and guarantee equality of treatment, social justice, protection of civil rights and freedom from racial discrimination; and

“Whereas, the Los Angeles Unified School District is involved in a process to transform schools to improve student academic achievement and social behavior by having all students college prepared, career ready and performing at proficiency and advanced levels. Therefore, be it

“Resolved that the LAUSD Board of Education publicly recognizes its responsibility as the governing board of one of this nation’s leading educational institutions to serve as committed advocates for equality of every student, to be champions of social justice and civil rights and to hold accountable all parties involved in IDesign [Partnership] and the transformation process to adhere to these same access and non-discriminatory standards; and be it finally

“Resolved that a statement of agreement with the district’s position on access and equity will be specifically incorporated in all MOU’s and signed by all parties prior to the approval/acceptance of any LAUSD partnership or joint venture involving students.”

This resolution will be debated by the school board at its Aug. 25 meeting.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

William said on Wednesday, Aug 5 at 7:57 PM

The universal and global language of contracts is in English not Spanish. Why is this Country so focused on destroying the English language and American Culture?

27362824
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

j holguin said on Monday, Jul 20 at 9:53 PM

As a member of the Social Economic and Justice Committee of SEIU Local 99 we were appalled at the discrimination by the Mayor's 10 partner schools.

26468001
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

American First said on Sunday, Jul 19 at 4:46 PM

Thanks NoHo, you're correct and I knew that.

26377786
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

NoHo Mom said on Sunday, Jul 19 at 9:36 AM

American First: it's spelled "appalled".

26361794
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

American First said on Saturday, Jul 18 at 10:34 AM

As a born U.S. Citizen of Mexican descent I am appauled. If parents want their children to be educated in Spanish they need to go back to Mexico, or pay for it themselves.

26318829
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

WATTS UP! said on Friday, Jul 17 at 10:15 PM

This summer session was open to ALL students, even to those that were not in the dual language program. Parents were given several opportunities to sign up.

26298536
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

curious said on Friday, Jul 17 at 9:58 AM

Don't you want your kids to be competitive in the future? It is harder and harder to get into college. Affirmative action is no longer. If we want this community to thrive, we have to prepare students for a K-16 career, because K-12 gets you nowhere these days. Maybe the kids didn't want to take the class because their parents' attitudes discouraged them to see it as a beneficial opportunity.

26261692
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Friday, Jul 17 at 9:54 AM

"This is a program being offered to Spanish speaking students ONLY. " That was not stated in the original article. In fact, the article states, "no child who does not speak Spanish (read: no Black child) is in it." This does not mean English speakers were invited and denied participation. Ritter employees themselves have stated this was offered to all students but only the Spanish speakers accepted. Learning a 2nd or 3d language is a tremendous benefit to all students; the younger the better.

26261389
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Anonymous said on Friday, Jul 17 at 9:33 AM

If funds are available for this school, then why are funds not available for other schools with the district? I smell a rat.

26259852
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

MadMommy said on Friday, Jul 17 at 9:27 AM

This is an elementary school summer program. This is a program being offered to Spanish speaking students ONLY. English speaking students aren't welcome there. That IS discrimination to every child that speaks the language of OUR country. Shame on you!

26259407
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Curious said on Thursday, Jul 16 at 10:24 PM

How is this not equal access? Spanish is a subject, just like math and science. In fact, all CA students are required to take 2 years of a foreign language to qualify for college. It seems this program offered Ritter students (who chose to take advantage of it) a chance to get a leg up in meeting this requirement. They should be commended, not castigated for this. I think Ms. Pleasant just wants to make waves to get readership. And people are falling for it.

26235372
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

RJ said on Thursday, Jul 16 at 9:35 PM

The article speaks of federal laws that guarantee equal access, civil rights, non discrimination. LAUSD has said "no summer school". This school is having summer school but only for Spanish Speakers. Equal access is a civil right of all children even in LA even if we do have a Latino Mayor and School superintendent and No one needs to tell these two or put it in any agreement. It is understood. If the mayor wants to discriminate he can do so on his own private property.

26234004
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Curious said on Thursday, Jul 16 at 8:14 PM

In a dual immersion program, the dual part means members of both the dominant language (English) and second language (in this case Spanish, I presume) would both be present to learn from each other. Ms. Pleasant, are you trying to say that no member of the English speaking community was enrolled in this class? That is important, because in many communities, learning a second language is not considered racism, but a valuable acquisition that will make children competitive in the future.

26231039
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

Los Angeles Wave and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

ON DEMAND

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.