Bottom Line: Forced deal reveals true intentions of the trial that wasn’t

By BETTY PLEASANT, Contributing Editor

Tools

Despite having been charged by the Los Angeles County district attorney with three felony crimes — including misappropriation of public funds — former Inglewood Mayor Roosevelt Dorn accepted a prosecution deal and pleaded guilty Monday to one misdemeanor charge of conflict of interest and was fined $1,000.

As part of the deal, Dorn resigned as Inglewood’s mayor Sunday, was given two years probation and the 75-year-old minister and retired judge was barred from ever seeking public office again.

In an interview Sunday before he accepted District Attorney Steve Cooley’s deal, Dorn said he was going to accept the deal, resign from office and plead to a misdemeanor because Cooley and Judge George G. Lomeli were forcing him to do so, as he had been put in a situation that accepting the D.A.’s offer was the only thing he could do. Dorn said Cooley had no intentions of having those three felonies with which he charged Dorn in June 2008 go to trial, and Lomeli actively worked from his judicial bench to strip Dorn of all of the means he had to defend himself at a trial, should one ever materialize.

The charges against Dorn were serious, and for the past 18 months the former mayor faced four years in prison if convicted of them and he had been paying two lawyers lots of money to prepare for his trial, defend him in court and keep him out of prison. So, what happened Monday?

The prospect of a trial went away, the specter of prison vanished, those serious charges against him disappeared, he was fined $1,000 (which is less than that for a lone driver caught in a carpool lane), and he resigned from office. That’s what this whole elaborate and expensive farce was all about — forcing Dorn out of a rather rinky-dink office. (We’re not talking about the mayor of say, Los Angeles, New York or Chicago, here.)

If Cooley had proof that Dorn had misappropriated public funds by unlawfully being compensated for taking out a home improvement loan from the city of Inglewood, it was his job to convict him and put him in prison. That’s what we pay Cooley to do, to punish people who hurt us or steal our money. The people of the city of Inglewood and we taxpayers of the County of Los Angeles deserve to have Dorn tried and convicted. But, if a trial was held, then Dorn would have had the opportunity to defend himself, which is something neither Cooley nor Lomeli would allow.

During a pretrial hearing last month, Lomeli ruled that Dorn could not call two independent experts on government codes as witnesses for his defense. The judge ruled then that Dorn could only call experts from Inglewood to testify in his defense. That same day, Lomeli ruled that Dorn, who had been a Superior Court judge for 18 years, could not serve as co-counsel in his own defense. Those rulings were unprecedented, mean-spirited and designed to significantly diminish Dorn’s ability to mount a strong defense.

Last week, Dorn’s attorneys went before Lomeli with the names of two Inglewood government code experts whom they wanted to testify in his defense: Timothy Wanamaker, the city administrator, and Wanda Brown, the city treasurer. Lomeli ruled they would not be allowed to testify either, after ruling last month that they were the only kind of people he would allow on the stand! How dastardly and calculating was that?! Out goes Dorn’s defense, en toto, and in comes the D.A.’s weak misdemeanor offer and, evidently, a tacit acknowledgment that he really didn’t do anything wrong — at least, nothing worth 18 months of hell, thousands of dollars in personal legal fees, and thousands of public dollars in court and prosecution costs.

Dorn and his attorneys had fashioned what they deemed a fine defense against the state’s flimsy and over-reaching case against the mayor, but when Lomeli got through last week, Dorn had nothing. The only way he was left to defend himself was to stand before the jury and scream: “I am innocent! I am innocent! I am innocent!” Cooley and Lomeli had no intentions of having Dorn deal with those charges against him in a court of law, as is supposed to be every American’s constitutional right.

This whole stressful, life-shortening mess served no one well except Cooley. The people deserved the conviction of a person proved guilty of misappropriating their funds. Dorn deserved a fair shot at getting an acquittal of such a charge. But all Cooley wanted was to get him out of office by any means necessary. And that’s what he got.

You have indicated this comment should be removed.

Close

The comment has been submitted for review. Thank you .

Marilyn said on Friday, Jan 29 at 3:17 PM

Mr. Kirley, what is the difference between 'don't know' and 'can't remember'? Maybe you should go back and read what you said to this paper, and refresh your memory. Obviously it is you who has a touch of ignorance.

36636514
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Mason said on Friday, Jan 29 at 3:14 PM

If you are not guilty, then don't plead, regardless of what the DA wanted. Dorn was bragging at city council meetings that "he welcomed the trial, the courtroom is like my living room. I can't wait to go to trial". Well it really is true that action speaks louder than words. GUILTY AS CHARGED!

36636362
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Just the Facts said on Friday, Jan 29 at 11:38 AM

Betty says Cooley should have sent Dorn to prison. But the law is that a public official who loans himself public funds has to step down...even if he didn't mean to steal. Dorn got greedy. He broke the law and he shouldn't be the mayor. But our prisons are over-flowing with violent criminals. We don't need to fill them with 75 year old greedy politicians. But we DO need to get them out of office. Cooley did just the right thing.

36620004
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Larry Kirkley said on Friday, Jan 29 at 1:51 AM

Well, since my name is mentioned by someone who obviously is either ignorant of the facts, wasn't in that court room, or just hard of hearing. Larry Kirkley (me) never said that "I didn't remember if loans were taken out"..what was said was "I don't know"..because both Mayor Dorn and the City Treasurer obtained the loans from the City Administrator and at no time would I have been involved in the paperwork or the approval process. Additionally, the loans were obtained during or after I retired.

36587669
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Willie Agee said on Thursday, Jan 28 at 11:00 PM

Too bad he got caught. The gravy train is over, darn!!!!!!!!!!!

36584562
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Colleen said on Thursday, Jan 28 at 4:15 PM

It was time for Dorn to go, he did something stupid. He broke the law, simple, you get punished

36564112
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Marilyn said on Thursday, Jan 28 at 2:42 PM

You really are a imbecile to think we will believe anything you write. You are an embarrassment to the journalism world. You had your own trial in this paper with Larry Kirkley posing as your 'star' witness. However, when he took the stand in a REAL courtroom and was asked if Dorn and Brown took the loan, his response. "I can't remember." It is past time for you to stop LYING in your 'rinky dinky' column.

36558132
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Arianne said on Thursday, Jan 28 at 12:33 PM

Are you serious? If Dorn believed he was innocent, why didn't he just go to trail. Inglewood doesn't want Dorn, confer with some of the Inglewood residents, not just Dorn. Believe me we are HAPPY!

36547777
Inappropriate? Alert Us!

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

Los Angeles Wave and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

ON DEMAND

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.