Cynicism in the health care debate

By JOSEPH PHILLIPS

Tools

The current philosophy of governance — and this includes governance of the Democrat and Republican variety — is that there is tremendous capacity in government to better the lives of average folks; it is the power of administrative policy that can end poverty, cure disease, and ultimately save the planet. It is, alas, also the promise of happiness written in capital letters that entices “we the people” to grant government ever greater powers with which to work their magic.

Can’t find any authority in the Constitution for the actions of our government? “Why man, they are engaged in the serious business of saving humanity!”

Woe to those that forget that the church is in the business of virtue; government is in the business of power. To mistake one for the other is to, in the one case, risk the loss of your soul; in the other the loss of your liberty.

It all sounds a bit hysterical, I know, but I believe in math and two and two still makes four.

Consider the words of Rep. John Conyers, D-Mich. During a speech at a luncheon for the National Press Club, Conyers questioned the point of lawmakers reading the health care bill. There is no point in reading a bill that is 1,000 pages long, said Conyers, if you don’t “have two days and two lawyers to find out what it means after you read the bill.” 

Conyers is correct. And I am just cynical enough to believe that the length and legalese is purposeful. The door to interpretation and regulatory enforcement by bureaucrats must be left ajar. What we learn from Conyers is that the big picture is what is important.

And the big picture is always about control and power; it is also at the heart of the current discussion of health care reform. Another example of the purposeful inexactness of language. Why do we not talk about reforming medical care?

Health is the relative condition of the human body and is determined by a variety of factors, only one of which is medical care. Other factors that influence our health are diet, amount of exercise, heredity; there is even a growing body of evidence demonstrating that prayer, meditation and regular attendance at worship services extends life expectancy, improves the immune system and adds to the overall health of the individual.

It is not hysterical to begin to wonder if the tentacles of a government run “health care” system will not find their way into the food services industry, leisure activities and even our spiritual endeavors.

Consider that just last week the Los Angeles Times reported on a new study by the Urban Institute entitled: “Reducing Obesity: Policy Strategies from the Tobacco Wars.” In order to fight the obesity “epidemic” in America, the study recommends an excise tax on fattening foods. As sure as night follows day this is the first step down the road to “good food” and “bad food” as defined by bureaucrats in Washington, D.C. It is a step the administrative state requires.

The allure of universal health care to most Americans is that it sounds an awful lot like “free” health care. Protest if you like, but that is really what most Americans want. We want to be able to go to any doctor we choose, for whatever ailment we have, receive the most current and cutting edge treatment available and not have to come out of pocket. Nice work if you can get it.

The crisis in American “health care” is and will continue to be who pays for medical services and how much they pay. Because it is at bottom a financial issue, the question of policy will be driven by similar concerns. In order to control costs, those in charge will make financial decisions — not medical decisions — and policy makers will be encouraged to use their ever expanding power over our lives to address the crisis.

See if this sounds familiar: One way in which we can control the rising cost of health care is to try and make sure people are healthier and so need less medical care. Obese Americans account for more than $40 billion in annual “health care” spending. We need to prevent Americans from eating too much sugar, fat, red meat and on and on.

Have no fear, government will ride to the rescue with a myriad of laws, taxes and expanded regulatory powers all designed to protect us; make us happier and healthier. The fine print will have been ignored because the details simply don’t matter — at least not when you are engaged in the noble work of saving humanity from itself.

Joseph Phillips can be reached via his Web site at josephcphillips.com.

Add a comment

Name:

Comment: 1000 Characters Left

Los Angeles Wave and its affiliated companies are not responsible for the content of comments posted or for anything arising out of use of the above comments or other interaction among the users. We reserve the right to screen, refuse to post, remove or edit user-generated content at any time and for any or no reason in our absolute and sole discretion without prior notice, although we have no duty to do so or to monitor any Public Forum.

On Demand

This content requires the latest Adobe Flash Player and a browser with JavaScript enabled. Click here for a free download of the latest Adobe Flash Player.